The article “Can You Learn Anything From a Void,” (http://www.tnr.com/book/review/druggist-auschwitz-reluctant-accomplice?page=0,0) is written by Adam Kirsch,
and it is written to present the problems of the Nazi oppressive regime coming
to power and later on the Holocaust. The story of Victor Capesius shows the
fact that ordinary people were forced to sentence others to death or even kill
the prisoners themselves. In situation is also discussed in the film “180” http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7y2KsU_dhwI.
In the film the speaker is asking what people would do in the situation of
being ordered to kill a person by the “humanly” way with a gun or by burying
them alive with a bulldozer. If the person doesn’t kill them then they will be
killed. Most would say they would kill the people with the bulldozer because it
is the easiest way and they won’t give up their own life if someone else will
just take their place. One women says that she would kill the people and expect
some one else to stand against the killing of the millions of people. That same
woman goes on to ask, “Where were the German people during the Holocaust?” The
response was maybe they were all people that thought that someone else was
going to stop the horrible cleansing of the Jews people. It would be suicide to
go up against the Nazi regime and so people were afraid to stand against the
oppressive government, but oppressive governments have been a part of human
history since the first man left the tree of the African jungle behind. In the
setting of Macbeth, the middle ages,
most countries were ruled by a monarchy and they used feudalism to rule their
subjects. The largest class of people was the peasants, and they were like
slaves to their superiors and had little say in what happened in their own
lives. They were oppressed and taught to only follow commands so in the play Macbeth, Macbeth becomes crazy over
chances that other man will have a better claim to the Crown. He begins killing
innocent men to keep his crown. The men doing Macbeths biding knew nothing more
than to follow their master and do what he commands. They would have even less
chance of surviving going up against their king than going against the Nazi
Regime in the middle of the 1900s.
Leaping
forward in time to the year 2012, “the year the world is to end,” countries
that have been under oppressive governments have began to rise against their
governments as one, rebel against it and go to war against it. The people of Egypt over
threw their dictator and are trying to set up a fair government. The people of Libya have
defeated their Dictator in a civil war and have killed him, with the support of
NATO and the United Nations. It was a bloody and gruesome war with trained
soldiers against everyday citizen with guns. And for eleven months now the
citizens of Syria
have been protesting their government and have been getting shot, bombed, and
beaten for it. Why all of a sudden are the dictators collapsing from the
pressure of their people? The answer is knowledge. In the days of King Macbeth
and the Holocaust the people didn’t really know what was going on except what
their governments told them. They had no idea if other people were rebelling
and were oppressing to think that what they were doing was right and fine. In
the middle ages they had no idea that they could rebel against their master and
even in the mid 1900s they didn’t know they had many choices. The people in Germany were
brainwashed to think that their race was the only one made by God and that the
others had no right to life. The few people that tried to explain to the people
that the government was killing innocent people were quickly throne into the
gas chambers.
] When people
are forced to kill innocent people and are brainwashed no even think of other options
how are they too realize the magnitude of their actions? They couldn’t unless
they knew their options. If the Germans weren’t oppressed to think that the
killing was the Word of God and that the government needs the people to be a
government. They would have taken a second look at what they were doing, and
realized that what they were doing was wrong and rebelled against the Nazi
Regime. To be guilty of the murdering, they must be aware of it. Yes, many
might have been aware they were murdering people so they would be guilty. It
takes a lot of courage to go against authority and to do what is right.
Hi Tony,
ReplyDeleteNice response to the writing prompt. Thanks for providing the link to the video "180." It was certainly a powerful exploration of difficult issues. I really liked how you compared the themes presented in the article to those in the video and in our play in an attempt to answer a seemingly straightforward question: what constitutes murder? I also liked how you discussed modern uprisings against oppressive regimes, and attributed their successes to an increase in knowledge and ability to communicate. Your piece was a great example of how to creatively elaborate on an issue and connect it to similar phenomena. Good job.
Thank you, Mr Darby
ReplyDelete